7年前に「イスラエル勝利プロジェクト」が開始された。部分的な紹介をした過去ブログおよび関連するツィッターを以下に。
1．（http://itunalily.jp/wordpress/wp-admin/post.php?post=829&action）
Israel Victory Caucus Launch Event
28 Apr 2017
Israel Victory Caucus (CIVC) on April 27 on Capitol Hill
2．（https://x.com/ituna4011/status/873035429305397249）
Lily2@ituna4011
Israel Victory Project – Lily’s Room (id:itunalily2)
（https://itunalily2.hatenablog.com/entries/2017/06/09）
1:34 PM · Jun 9, 2017
3．（https://itunalily2.hatenablog.com/entry/20170609）
Israel National News（http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/230752）
Think ‘victory’
New project launched at Israeli universities champions a new approach to solving the Israeli-Palestinian Arab conflict.
8 June 2017
by Arutz Sheva Staff
A new project championing Israeli victory and Palestinian defeat was launched yesterday at a special conference held at Hebrew University, featuring MK Amir Ohana, Major General (res.) Dan Biton, Brigadier General (res.) Yossi Kuperwasser, and Maariv journalist Dr. Revital Amiran.
The Israel Victory Project, initiated by the US-based think tank, the Middle East Forum, offers a new approach to solving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
According to Middle East Forum, a resolution to the conflict will only occur once the Palestinians are defeated and give up the goal of destroying Israel and recognize Israel as the Jewish state.
4.（https://itunalily2.hatenablog.com/entry/20171212）
Israeli victory project & process
Israel Hayom (http://www.israelhayom.com/)
Knesset, Congress sister lobbies to push new agenda on Middle East conflict
13 November 2017
Sister lobbies formed with the backing of the Israel Victory Project, an initiative of the conservative Middle East Forum think tank • Lawmakers urge U.S. to allow Israel to break from Washington’s dictates to ensure it has the upper hand in the conflict.
Alongside U.S. President Donald Trump’s ongoing efforts to put together a framework for an Israeli-Palestinian peace deal, the Knesset Lobby for Promoting the Recognition of Israeli Victory and the U.S. Congressional Israel Victory Lobby are set to start working together on what they see as a solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in which Israel will emerge victorious.
5.（https://x.com/ituna4011/status/1559418262882254848）
Lily2@ituna4011
Israel Victory Can Solve the Palestinian Issue:
https://www.danielpipes.org/21364/israel-victory-can-solve-the-palestinian-issue#
《similar developments occurred in Turkey 100 years ago and in Japan 150 years ago. 》
2:54 PM · Aug 16, 2022
（転載終）
。。。。。。。。。。
そして、7年後の今……
（https://x.com/ituna4011/status/1800363263148114410）
Lily2@ituna4011
新しく本が出ました！
12:03 PM · Jun 11, 2024
69 Views
（https://x.com/ituna4011/status/1800338998239584266）
Lily2@ituna4011
Book announcement: Israel Victory
10:27 AM · Jun 11, 2024
（https://x.com/DanielPipes/status/1800171709951259097）
You reposted
Daniel Pipes دانيال بايبس @DanielPipes
My brand-new book, “Israel Victory: How Zionists Win Acceptance and Palestinians Get Liberated,” is now available at Amazon. The brief version: The Palestinian-Israeli conflict will come to an acceptable conclusion only with a Palestinian sense of defeat.
11:22 PM · Jun 10, 2024
5,353 Views
（転載終）
。。。。。。。。。。。
それから…….
（https://x.com/ituna4011/status/1801921831949189155）
Lily2@ituna4011
7年後の今日、新刊書が届きました。 ヘルツェルが夢想家、ベン・グリオンが楽観主義者、モシェダヤンが『ジューイッシュマザー』、シモンペレスが寸鉄人、だとの描写(pp.58-67)。 索引と引用注がないのが、たまにキズ。一読の価値あり。
7:16 PM · Jun 15, 2024
268 Views
（https://x.com/ituna4011/status/1801934033372528999）
Lily2@ituna4011
毎度のことながら、理論的で分析力に富む。どこまで実行可能かが問題ではある。 相変わらず、日本に関しては田母神俊雄氏のご指摘通りで、何ら変化なし(p.288)。だが、そこで怒っては負けだ。侮られない日本および日本人を目指して、着実に力をつけて、自分で自分を守るのだ。
オワコン記
8:05 PM · Jun 15, 2024
100 Views
（https://x.com/ituna4011/status/1801946897042800923）
Lily2@ituna4011
久しぶりにジャボティンスキーやイツハクシャミール氏を思い出したオワコンの私。冷徹な現実主義者こそが勝利へと導く。クラウゼヴィッツを田母神俊雄氏が解説された本があるらしい。注文済み。原書の邦訳は手元にあるが未読。
8:56 PM · Jun 15, 2024
47 Views
（https://x.com/ituna4011/status/1801949722342801578）
Lily2@ituna4011
但し、抑止力としての日本の核保有に関して、何年も前にパイプス氏に尋ねてみたところ、反対していない、とのことでした。また、アメリカの共和党寄りの方々は、日本が軍事力を上げることに賛成のようでした。
9:07 PM · Jun 15, 2024
25 Views
（https://x.com/ituna4011/status/1801961138290339924）
Lily2@ituna4011
実は私、著者よりも先に、ご著書を入手した模様です。たまにはオワコンにもいいことあります。
9:53 PM · Jun 15, 2024
31 Views
（2024年6月16日転載終）
………………
2024年6月28日：
本書の書評を以下に。
1．(https://www.jns.org/can-israel-win-by-winning/?fbclid=IwZXh0bgNhZW0CMTEAAR0-t3BS44cPff-c8gRJL77kxPj6hCjllbW9pUPSNdg3cbE6lp4vFXKQ0cA_aem_LRYVLutMCoMNp3-sPtFmvw)
Can Israel ‘Win by Winning’?
A review of Daniel Pipes’ “Israel Victory: How Zionists Win Acceptance and Palestinians Get Liberated.”
by Daniel Greenfield (an Israeli-born journalist who writes for conservative publications)
23 June 2024
JNS
A week before the Oct. 7 Hamas assault on Israel, veteran foreign policy expert Daniel Pipes, a former board member of the United States Institute of Peace and the president of the Middle East Forum, turned in the manuscript for his new book: “Israel Victory: How Zionists Win Acceptance and Palestinians Get Liberated.”
The foundational thesis of Pipes’ work, that Israel had spent far too much time conciliating the Islamic terrorist groups that dominate Gaza and the West Bank, offering them the promise of peace and prosperity, emerged from the rubble more relevant than ever.
“Israeli leaders seek to improve Palestinian economic welfare: I call this the policy of enrichment,” Pipes writes in “Israel Victory,” criticizing Israel for not adopting “the universal tactic of depriving an economy of resources, but…the opposite one of helping Palestinians to develop economically.”
The quintessential liberal fallacy also at the root of America’s failures in the War on Terror holds that wars are fought against regimes, not people. Even when Israel achieved its victories on the battlefield, it still believed that peace would come through mutual prosperity and befriending foes. This vision is alien to the region and rather than bringing peace has only perpetuated generations of war.
In the months before Oct. 7, Arab Muslim workers from Gaza were allowed in increasing numbers to work in Israel. And in the months since Oct. 7, Israel, under political pressure, has flooded Gaza with aid. The pre-10/7 appeasement failed to prevent the massacres, rapes and kidnappings and the post-10/7 benevolence only convinced Muslims in Gaza they would win.
“Israel Victory” contends that Israel can’t win through conciliation, it can only win by winning, and that furthermore, victory is ultimately the best possible outcome for both sides. Israel’s reticence to achieve a conclusive and decisive victory infused generations of Arab Muslims living in the West Bank and Gaza with the conviction that they can destroy Israel if they transform their societies into killing machines and turn over political power to terrorists.
It is as if instead of defeating Nazi Germany or Imperial Japan, the Allies had left a core regime and population intact and free to plot war for another 50 years. That’s what happened in Israel.
The dynamic in which we try to win over the Muslim world, only to have it reject us, to which we respond with even more concerted efforts to win it over, has become all too familiar to most of us. And it’s the dynamic that “Israel Victory” places at the heart of the conflict. The combination of relentless international pressure and the conviction that peace can only be achieved by winning hearts and minds, rather than wars, has created a doom spiral of “rejectionism” and “conciliation.”
“Rejectionism, however, will not collapse on its own. It must be broken. Only one party, Israel, can achieve this. Doing so will require major changes, indeed, a paradigm shift,” Pipes writes. “That means abandoning conciliation and returning to the eternal verities of war. I call this Israel Victory. More negatively but more accurately, it consists of Palestinian defeat.”
Essentially, for Israel to win, it has to defeat the enemy side not just enough to achieve a battlefield victory, but to finally convince it that any further fighting can only be futile.
In an era where everyone from Obama and Biden to some of their opponents on the right complain about “endless wars”, the idea of ending wars by winning them seems radical.
But endless wars persist, the way that many other problems do, because we have abandoned the common sense solutions that everyone used to understand in favor of new models that don’t work. In “Israel Victory” Pipes briefly and ably traces the history of the collision between Israeli optimism and Muslim hatred. He shows that, contrary to leftist myth, Israeli governments and leading figures like Moshe Dayan bent over backward to accommodate and appease the Arab Muslim population.
In one revealing passage, the book relates an incident that took place after the victory of the Six-Day War.
The Israelis dispatched combines to help Arab Muslims occupying parts of the West Bank bring in the harvest.
“I was among those who conquered the place,” one of the drivers recalled. “We are incapable of being conquerors. A month before I was risking my life, and now here I was helping them harvest their grain.”
The sentiment is a Rorschach test. It appears noble to many westerners, yet in societies where an individual’s place is determined by hierarchies built on force, it conveys a destabilizing weakness. Westerners think that they are liberating societies when they are actually taking away their verities and replacing them with ambiguities. And these societies, whether in Gaza or Iraq and Afghanistan, rapidly embrace those more traditional elements that offer cultural stability and the ultimate promise that what was once true can be made so again.
In the Middle East, modern societies have won military victories, but not cultural ones. If we want to stop constantly fighting military campaigns, we will have to win the cultural wars as well.
And this may require Israel, America, the United Kingdom and other modern societies to do things that they are uncomfortable with, that appear to violate their values and disturb their sense of moral order.
Many dysfunctional children grow up in homes where the parents try to be their “friends” because they are uncomfortable acting as authority figures.
To end the cycle of appeasement and violence, the Israelis and all of us may have to learn to stop trying to be “friends” with our enemies and get comfortable with being conquerors.
(End)
＊上記と同執筆者による同文の原稿が下記にも再掲された。知る限り、同原稿が4つの媒体に掲載されたことになる。(Lily)
Gatestone Institute (https://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/20728/can-israel-win-by-winning?fbclid=IwZXh0bgNhZW0CMTEAAR3Krydx7Qah-3Lepot6YPBSyBUeXG2bQU4Dfk8upxDBcfbPXbqLZdct90M_aem_-Fg-DxU0LEFGgjLN4JWi3Q)
Can Israel ‘Win by Winning’?
A review of Daniel Pipes’ ‘Israel Victory’
by Daniel Greenfield
25 June 2024
The Jewish Star (https://www.thejewishstar.com/stories/pipes-book-tells-how-israel-wins-by-winning,23745?fbclid=IwZXh0bgNhZW0CMTEAAR0d4Gc6hI0tq4k9M7Gan27kh5BKm4czOGqbRGdPhIhs9vG2YuWrY4vWmgY_aem_wPahAbUZiUv6sEk4sDrwdw)
Pipes book tells how Israel wins by winning
26 June 2024
（2024年6月28日記）
…………….
2024年8月13日追記：
（https://x.com/ituna4011/status/1821711932430417964）
Lily2@ituna4011
Why Palestinian-Israeli Diplomacy Always Fails and Only an Israeli Victory Will End the Conflict (danielpipes.org)
https://danielpipes.org/22300/why-palestinian-israeli-diplomacy-always-fails…
12年前を思い出す。懐かしい程、興味深いインタビュー。理論的には妥当だが、実践は困難か。
9:55 AM · Aug 9, 2024
（2024年8月13日転載終）
……………
2024年10月17日追記：
（https://x.com/DanielPipes/status/1846624148841185593）
Daniel Pipes دانيال بايبس @DanielPipes
And here is the other stand-out picture, of my father’s father, #MarekPipes, standing on the right on a trip to Stockholm in 1929. What style.
3:48 AM · Oct 17, 2024
（https://x.com/ituna4011/status/1846636962402410984）
Lily2@ituna4011
パイピシュ先生の父方おじいちゃま。リチャード先生の自伝Vixiにも登場されます。
4:38 AM · Oct 17, 2024
（2024年10月17日転載終）